California School Trends vs. GreatSchools
Both sites help families compare California schools and see state test results. California School Trends makes the fundamentals easy to understand with year-by-year charts of reading and math proficiency. GreatSchools combines test results with 1–10 school ratings, family reviews, and an address-based school finder.
What you can do on each site
✅ Available · ❌ Unavailable
| Feature | California School Trends | GreatSchools |
|---|---|---|
| See year-by-year trends in reading and math proficiency | Available | Unavailable |
| See the share of students meeting reading and math standards | Available | Available |
| See reading and math results by grade or student group | Available | Available |
| Compare schools side by side | Available | Available |
| Explore reading and math results from a statewide map | Available | Unavailable |
| Find nearby schools on a map | Available | Available |
| Look up National Merit semifinalist counts by California school | Available | Unavailable |
| Read research on schools and student outcomes | Available | Available |
| Find district school board members and election years | Available | Unavailable |
| See a rating for individual student growth compared with peers | Unavailable | Available |
| Read family reviews on school profiles | Unavailable | Available |
| See a college readiness rating for high schools | Unavailable | Available |
Sources. California School Trends school profile · California School Trends district profile · California School Trends statewide map · California National Merit semifinalists · GreatSchools school profile · GreatSchools district profile · GreatSchools California directory · GreatSchools research reports · GreatSchools comparison tool
Why a school can rate higher with lower reading proficiency
Proficiency is the percentage of tested students who met or exceeded the state standard. GreatSchools’ Test Scores rating compares a school’s test performance with other schools in the state. Its Student Progress rating compares students’ test-score growth with that of academically similar students. GreatSchools weights the available ratings to get the overall score. California School Trends data sources · GreatSchools ratings methodology
A school can have strong student growth while many students are still working toward the state standard. Two Contra Costa schools show how that affects the overall rating. Pleasant Hill Middle serves grades 6–8 in Mt. Diablo Unified, and Springhill Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Lafayette. The table uses their 2025 reading results and the weights GreatSchools published for its 2026 ratings.
| Measure | Pleasant Hill Middle | Springhill Elementary |
|---|---|---|
| Overall rating (2026) | 9/10 | 7/10 |
| State reading proficiency (2025) | 58.9% | 82.5% |
| Test Scores rating × weight | 8/10 × 40.5% | 10/10 × 59.5% |
| Student Progress rating × weight | 9/10 × 59.5% | 2/10 × 40.5% |
At Pleasant Hill, Student Progress was the stronger of the two ratings and carried more weight. At Springhill, Test Scores carried more weight, and the lower Student Progress rating brought down the overall score. Using the published weights gives 8.6 for Pleasant Hill and 6.8 for Springhill before GreatSchools rounds them.
Sources. Pleasant Hill’s GreatSchools rating · Pleasant Hill’s state test results · Springhill’s GreatSchools rating · Springhill’s state test results
Is your school improving in reading and math?
Pleasant Hill Middle improved in both subjects from 2024 to 2026. The school’s trend charts show how much. Reading proficiency rose 14.7 percentage points to 64.2%, and math proficiency rose 4.0 points to 46.1%. Pleasant Hill Middle’s test scores and trends
When to use each site
- Use California School Trends to see whether reading or math proficiency has improved at schools serving the same grades. Compare three Pleasant Hill middle schools · Compare three Lafayette elementary schools
- Use GreatSchools if you’re considering a move and want to see which schools serve an address, or if you want to hear from families at a school on your list. Look up an address · Read Pleasant Hill Middle reviews
FAQ
Why does GreatSchools use one overall rating?
GreatSchools uses a single 1–10 score to give families a quick way to compare schools in the same state. It combines available ratings for test scores, student growth, and college readiness. About GreatSchools ratings
How can a high GreatSchools rating obscure low reading or math proficiency?
Strong student growth can lift the overall rating even when many students score below the state standard. The Test Scores rating also combines reading and math, so a stronger result in one subject can make a weaker result in the other less visible. Check the proficiency percentages for each subject to see where students stand. GreatSchools ratings methodology · Pleasant Hill Middle’s reading and math results
Why might the two sites show different proficiency percentages for the same school?
Check that both numbers use the same test year, subject, grade, and student group. If they still differ, look up the school and year in the state’s results. California’s official test results
Which grades count in a school’s test results?
California gives its statewide reading and math tests in grades 3–8 and 11. At a K–5 school like Springhill, the results cover tested students in grades 3–5. California Department of Education testing schedule